The Sierra Star Logo

A losing proposition | Sierra Star

×
HOME SUBSCRIBE
  • E-edition
    • All News
    • Local News
    • Obituaries
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Weather
    • Submit a News Tip
    • All Living
    • Entertainment
  • Sports
    • All Opinion
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Submit a Letter
    • Classifieds
    • Cars
    • Jobs
    • Homes
    • Apartments
    • Placead
    • Legals
  • Webcams
  • Archives
  • Customer Service

Dr. Bill Atwood

A losing proposition

My Thoughts

By Dr. Bill Atwood

    ORDER REPRINT →

August 15, 2017 01:55 PM

Last week there was a letter to the editor of the Fresno Bee from a lady named Bennie that addressed her opinion regarding the high-speed rail that this state is funding. Bennie works in the Bay Area, but after 30-40 years in the real estate business she states she cannot afford the high priced homes in that area. She wants to live in the Madera/Fresno County area. Her solution is that the rest of us fund a multibillion dollar train so that she may live here and work there.

Getting back to Bennie’s solution. The bullet train is an expense we cannot afford. I have written before about the cost incurred in just laying the track on fairly level ground in the Manteca area is costing this state $300 per inch. That is just track, not a train, not one train, simply track. The governor has not explained how he is going to suspend the laws of physics and gravity when his train must pass over the Tehachapis. I can’t see tunneling as that range is prone to earthquakes, and I really can’t envision people willing to ride through miles of tunnels in such an area.

The train folks are promising service to many areas. Do the math. The train departs Bakersfield for Sacramento. That 285-mile trip takes four hours in your car. The folks in Shafter, Delano, Earlimart, Pixley, Tulare, Visailia, Selma, Reedley, Clovis, Fresno, Madera, Chowchilla, Merced, Atwater, Turlock, Ceres, Salida, Manteca, Stockton, Lodi, and Elk Grove all expect service since they are being taxed to support the project.

The 21 cities mentioned, plus the cities of Bakersfield and Sacramento, show the problem. The HSR train will not be able to get up to a fast speed before it must stop at any one of those listed stations. Suppose the train only stops at seven stations and the train folks allow for a 10-minute stopover. That is 70 minutes just sitting in the station. In the 40 miles or so between one stop and another the train will not get to a high speed. The train will probably take three hours to get you there. You saved one hour and don’t have a car to use in Sacramento. Be sure to add in your waiting time in Bakersfield for the train.

Amtrak has proven the railroads knew what they were talking about in the 1970s when they pulled out of passenger service because it’s a losing proposition. The only speedy part of high-speed rail will be the dollars flowing from our pockets to build this, and then to subsidize it once it is running between some towns and not others. However, Bennie wants you and I to cover her transportation costs because her salary/commissions can’t afford her the lifestyle she desires.

Years ago I decided that I did not want to live in the LA area. Teachers make far better salaries there than they earn in this area. I want to live here and so I moved here. I accepted the lower salary as a cost of living in such a fabulous area with you great folks. According to Bennie’s thinking, the state should have funded a transportation system to allow me the privilege of living here and working there.

It isn’t your responsibility to provide me with a ride to work. If Bennie wants to work in the Bay Area she needs to work harder to buy a home near there and not expect us to fund here travels.

She wants a free ride. I don’t want to buy her ticket.

  Comments  

Videos

Hail and rain pour down on Bass Lake

Hail and snow rain down on Oakhurst during cold winter storm

View More Video

Read Next

Dr. Bill Atwood

A liberal and a conservative meet

By Dr. Bill Atwood Special to the Sierra Star

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 12, 2019 10:04 AM

Dr. Bill Atwood represents a conservative voice in the Sierra Star of Oakhurst, CA. In his latest column, he describes a conversation he had while getting a little help from a new friend.

KEEP READING

MORE DR. BILL ATWOOD

The FBI and the ridiculous show of force arresting Roger Stone

Dr. Bill Atwood

The FBI and the ridiculous show of force arresting Roger Stone

February 05, 2019 09:39 AM

Dr. Bill Atwood

We deserve better

January 31, 2019 10:24 AM
Karen Pence is going back to school to teach, and mainstream media has a field day

Dr. Bill Atwood

Karen Pence is going back to school to teach, and mainstream media has a field day

January 21, 2019 11:26 AM
The new message of the Democrat Party is scary

Dr. Bill Atwood

The new message of the Democrat Party is scary

January 17, 2019 02:33 AM
And so it begins

Dr. Bill Atwood

And so it begins

January 10, 2019 02:45 AM

Dr. Bill Atwood

Predicting the future. Because that’s where we’ll spend the rest of our lives.

January 03, 2019 03:33 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Sierra Star App

Subscriptions
  • Digital & Home Subscriptions
  • Digital Replica Edition
Learn More
  • Archives
  • Customer Service
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Advertising
  • Advertise
  • Place an Ad
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story