Fresno Flats feud went to the dogs

Pieces of the Past

Bill CoateMarch 7, 2012 

When S.W. Westfall was elected to the job of sheriff, he knew that the task would not be easy. Madera County had its share of trouble makers, and it took a great deal of patience to ensure domestic tranquility in the face of the criminal element that roamed the countryside.

Occasionally, however, it wasn't the robbers, drunks, or burglars who broke the peace. Sometimes it was the law-abiding and highly respected citizens that gave the sheriff fits. Take, for instance, that time when two of Oakhurst's most highly thought-of families almost brought tragedy to the town in what began as a simple dog fight.

We are not going to give the family names, for their descendants still reside in Madera County. We will simply refer to them by the initials of the husbands, R.W. and E.O. Readers who are interested in nailing down their identities are urged to look into the Aug. 22 issue of the Madera Tribune.

Now, to the story.

It should have been a pleasant evening visit. The two Oakhurst families had been friends for quite awhile. There was lots of daylight after work during the month of August and they enjoyed each other's company.

Just after supper one evening, R.W. took his family and their border collie dog and strolled over to E.O.'s place. The women folk, including R.W.'s daughter, went inside the house to visit while the men swapped yarns out in the barn.

It just so happened that E.O. had a dog of his own, a bulldog with an uneven disposition. While the men were engaged in conversation in the barn, the dogs were getting acquainted in the barnyard. No one knows what started it, but suddenly the collie and the bulldog began a quarrel that became a fight to the death. The sound of the combat brought R.W. and E.O. running out of the barn and the women out of the house. Everyone watched in horror as the two animals tried to kill each other. It was R.W. who reached them first and attempted to separate them, all to no avail.

Before he knew it, E.O.'s bulldog had a death grip on the throat of R.W.'s collie. It would have been the end of the dog had someone not taken action. R.W. did just that. He pulled out a huge hunting knife and stabbed E.O.'s dog to death right before his neighbor's eyes. When the collie limped away to lick his wounds, R.W. thought the worst was over. He was sadly mistaken.

When E.O saw the killing of his dog, he lost his head and ran into his house. Within seconds, he emerged carrying a loaded rifle, apparently intent on extracting retribution. Fortunately, E.O.'s wife intervened and took the gun, but that didn't stop her husband. While R.W. was tending to his collie, E.O. hit him with a haymaker that sent him reeling. R.W. got to his feet, and within moments the two men took up where the dogs left off. Now it was the women's turn to step in.

Each wife grabbed her husband and somehow managed to put an end to the fisticuffs, but the burning anger lingered. E.O. ordered R.W. and his family off his place with a nasty threat. He warned R.W. to be on the lookout because he intended to kill not only his collie, but his daughter as well. R.W. returned home stunned at the turn of events. After a sleepless night, during which he kept watch for E.O., R.W. saddled up his horse and rode to Madera to see Sheriff Westfall. He explained the source of his concern, and within an hour or two, a warrant was issued for E.O.'s arrest.

Now it was Westfall's turn to be apprehensive. What would he find when he went up to Oakhurst to arrest E.O.? Had the man's anger melted, or did he still have murder in his eyes? Fortunately, E.O. had had time to cool off, and the sheriff had no trouble bringing him to Madera.

On Aug. 22, 1914, E.O. appeared before Judge J.W. Montague, "looking to be anything but a bad or dangerous man." He denied making any threats toward R.W. or his family, but he did admit to expressing the desire to kill his dog.

Judge Montague put E.O.'s bail at $100 and admonished him to attempt to patch things up with R.W.

Westfall kept his fingers crossed. Perhaps it was the night in jail. Maybe it was the passing of a little time. It could have been that down deep inside, E.O. was really a reasonable man. No doubt the presence of Sheriff Westfall had something to do with it, but as he escorted E.O. back to Oakhurst, he was ready for reconciliation.

The record does not say who made the first move. It was nevertheless initiated, and the two antagonists became friends once more. The charges were dropped, and life returned to normal for everyone except the bulldog.

Not every foothill feud had such an ending. In an era when principles ran deep and honor was held high, the odds against E.O. and R.W. ever speaking to each other again were fairly high, which says quite a bit about the arbitrating powers of Sheriff Westfall.

When he returned to Madera from Oakhurst, he once again focused his attention on the ne'er-do-wells who normally kept him busy. He had defused a potential disaster and kept the peace. Two of Madera County's respected farmers had kept their dignity and their lives. It was all in a day's work.

The Sierra Star is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service